The United Federation of Teachers - A Union of Professionals

October 12, 2008  

home> letters to the editor> news and issues> new york teacher> letters to the editor> archive - letters to the ny teacher

Category Archive

Speakout was right on

Peter Goodman’s article “What teaching is all about” [June 5] is right on the mark

Be grateful for your union

I am 82 years old and retired from the New York City Board of Education in 1981. Every month when my pension check comes in, I thank my lucky stars and say God bless Al Shanker for the vision and wonderful leadership he gave our union.

The courage of Ponsie Hillman

Ponsie Hillman was a woman of courage. Abuse couldn’t stop her from fighting for our members and for her union. So when we talk about union solidarity, please remember the name of Ponsie Hillman and how she stood with the union in our most difficult of times.

Fairness needed at Canarsie

As you know, Canarsie HS is phasing out. Mini schools have opened on the campus. That veteran teachers cannot get a job with new schools because their salary level is too high is bad enough. To make it even worse, the new mini schools get many features and upgrades that Canarsie HS never had.

How money is spent should be priority

It is certainly appropriate for the UFT to pressure the DOE to restore lost funds. However, by focusing primarily on lost income, we run the risk of overlooking the all-important issue of misspent dollars. How money is spent is just as important as how much money is available.

Sun blasted for mayoral control stance

Court pick the ‘Supreme’ election issue

Sen. John McCain has stated that he would — if elected — appoint justices resembling Justices Alito and Roberts. These two justices along with Justices Scalia and Thomas would turn the clock back even further than the current court has if McCain has the chance to appoint new justices.

Keep fighting for what’s right

My heartiest congratulations to President Randi Weingarten for holding the feet of Chancellor Joel Klein, Mayor Bloom­berg and especially the Department of Education to the fire. She’s absolutely right to make them keep their promises for

Only looking good

The extreme emphasis on looking good, as opposed to being good, has infected the academic world like a plague.

Anti-McCain column right on

I hope all members of our union will pay attention to the excellent article that laid out some of the ways in which John McCain supports the Bush agenda.

Retirees show their solidarity

Retirees have in the past and will continue to show full support for our brothers and sisters who are in-service.

PIP a valued program

The heart and soul of the UFT’s Peer Intervention Program is its staff that is made up of hard-working, talented professionals dedicated to New York City’s school children.

We need a better attendance policy

With the intense clamor for improving the quality of education focused on standardized tests and other “objective” data, perhaps it is time to revisit student attendance requirements.

The rewards of teaching the arts

To the Editor: The article “Exploring your imagination” captured the essence of what Lincoln Center Institute is about.

Gifted and Talented woes

How can the DOE have sent out a letter to a parent congratulating her child for being accepted into a Gifted and Talented program when none existed in the district?

Focus on ‘real issues’

I don’t know what all the fuss was about having Holy Thursday off. Church services begin in the evening as this day commemorates The Last Supper.

More reasons for arts

In addition to the reasons cited by UFT Vice President Leo Casey for the need to continue funding and providing arts education to New York City’s public school students, a few more must be noted.

Jamaica HS still breathing

Jamaica HS is not closing. The New York Teacher [April 24] erroneously printed that the Department of Education has decided “to close the school

Those were the days

Edmund Janko’s “A super library” [Speakout, April 10] must echo what so many of us retirees feel

Misleading propaganda

The derogatory and misleading advertisements appearing in The New York Times suggest that the UFT’s primary purpose is to protect incompetent teachers or, in effect, prevent them from being fired.

Tenure victory was crucial

When a teacher is excessed, many people believe it is due to incompetence. I am constantly defending myself concerning the reason I was excessed.

Lessons of an ATR

When a teacher is excessed, many people believe it is due to incompetence. I am constantly defending myself concerning the reason I was excessed.

Lobbyist’s ads are trash

A member disagrees with the anti-teacher union ads put out by the Center for Union Facts.

Questionable outsourcing

I was disturbed about the foreign consultant firm that was engaged by the Department of Education to evaluate schools.

Conservatively speaking ...

As a retired teacher and a conservative, I feel compelled to reply to the [March 13] letter by Ed Beller.

Thanks from a principal

I just want to let you know that I thought your reporter, Ron Isaac, did a great job on the article about IS 318 and the positive working relationship that the Council of School Supervisors and Administrators and the UFT have developed within our educational community.

Overload fight continues

Many thanks for coverage of the crisis that school psychologists and school social workers are facing since the reorganizations of special education began in 2003.

Grading system misses mark

The academic propensity for looking good, as opposed to being good, should be viewed as endemic to the excessive vanity of our pedagogic times.

Congratulations on securing 55/25 agreement

I must offer UFT President Randi Weingarten my sincerest thanks for assuring New York City public school teachers the 55/25 plan, as I considered it a cornerstone in our negotiations with the DOE.

The strength of physical education classes

UFT Vice President for Academic High Schools Leo Casey states in a Feb. 14 article headlined “UFT VP: Tweed neglects phys ed” that “the attitude of the New York City school system might as well be ‘Let them eat cake.’” I have to agree.

Call for a Shanker stamp

It would not be remiss to approach Al Shanker’s political opposites and request a stamp be issued in his honor as a strong labor leader and promoter of academic excellence.

Solution to parking problems?

I wanted to highlight one aspect of the change that your readers may welcome and that may change how they feel about mass transit: pretax commuter benefits.

No ‘Stern’ criticism?

When neo-con Sol Stern contributed a lengthy piece, I was sure there would be a rebuttal forthcoming from UFT President Randi Weingarten or Vice President Leo Casey. But none came.

Thank all thanked teachers

I just received the Feb. 14 New York Teacher and was disappointed that you only highlighted a few of us who were honored at the “Thank A Teacher” ceremony.

Tax benefit for New York State residents

New York State residents who file itemized federal income tax returns might benefit from the sales tax paid throughout the year.

Hillary cares and so do we

When it’s time to vote you can always count on seniors.

Boob tube strikes again

A contestant on a reality TV show, who supposedly works with special-needs children, referred to autistic children as “retards.” The network on which this show airs has refused to take action against the show.

Special needs discrimination exists

I am a parent of a child who has special needs. In my opinion, she has not been challenged to the best of her abilities to succeed academically.

‘Special’ welcome wanted

I believe we are seeing a trend where administrations are not so willing to welcome the special-needs student into their schools.

DOE’s numbers game

The Department of Education considers children as nothing more than numbers.

Airing an opposing view

I was pleasantly surprised that the same issue of the New York Teacher that carried UFT President Randi Weingarten’s discussion of why the union has endorsed Hillary Clinton also included my letter titled “Why the endorsement?”

A valuable resource overlooked

Moms as teachers need F-status and schools need us.

Quality, not quantity

The emphasis in the academic community on quantification over qualification should certainly raise warning signs to those of us committed to high academic achievement.

Fewer parking permits means better air quality

A writer is surprised about the opposition to curtailing parking permits for city workers.

ATRs are second class citizens

After 21 years in the New York City school system, I am “just a sub” or, at least, that is the way I am referred to by administrators and students at the school to which I am assigned as an ATR.

Why the endorsement?

Being a life-long, dedicated union member, I am perplexed that the AFT supports Sen. Hillary Clinton.

50 in a class

When I read the article “Time to make low class size a reality," I am left to wonder if that would include physical education classes. If not, why not?

Amped to teach

A retiree offers a suggestion to any teacher in today’s often trying situations.

Vote for Hillary

When I read the article “Time to make low class size a reality," I am left to wonder if that would include physical education classes. If not, why not?

Wrong on religion

Former Massachusetts Gov. Willard “Mitt” Romney stated in his speech on religion that “freedom requires religion” and “religion requires freedom.”

New transfer policy unfair to senior teachers

Maybe more members of the UFT are “settling into new classrooms” but how many of them are at the top of the seniority list?

He’s no survivor

While I do agree that it’s impossible to write a book while teaching, Dan Brown should not be saluted [“Survivor,” Dec. 6]. He’s no survivor!

Bloomberg’s hit squad

By hiring a team of lawyers and former principals to go after tenured teachers, Mayor Bloomberg has hit an all-time low.

No regrets

One retiree says thanks for the classroom memories.

Compensate those victimized

Unless the victims of the DOE’s “rubber rooms” are compensated for the pain and suffering that they have already endured, justice cannot be served.

Administrators get off, teachers go to rubber rooms

As a retired teacher from the Bronx, I have seen at close hand the abuses that send people into rubber rooms.

Training for new mothers

A per-diem teacher tells Chancellor Klein about the need for parent education, especially for mothers in the LYFE program.

A thrilling scene

There are 28,000 child care providers. They are proud of their UFT affiliation and the UFT is proud that they are our new members.

Listen to those with classroom experience

There is a spate of administrative personnel of limited experience who have not come up through the ranks of classroom instruction.

Recycling codes need to be followed in schools

I started and ran a recycling program in Brooklyn for two years. It was no easy task.

Growing need for health classes

With the societal increase in childhood obesity and now the emergence of MRSA and its impact on school populations at all levels, it would be nice to have licensed teachers of health (per New York State requirement) in all of our middle and high schools.

Housing program makes retiree proud

I read the article in the New York Teacher about the housing development for our members. Congratulations to all included including the Teachers’ Retirement System Board and UFT President Randi Weingarten regarding this very important development.

Members should request cancer screening from dentists

I was a New York City 6th-grade teacher for more than 25 years and am also a wife and mother of dentists. So I read the article “Preventive dental care saves pains in your mouth and wallet” [Health Benefits Checkup supplement, Sept. 20] with great concern.

Paper treats secretaries unfairly

I have a gripe. Can you tell me why the school secretary seems to be left out of so much in the union paper?

Gibran Academy article raises worthwhile questions

Even though the [Oct. 4] Speakout column headlined “The folly of the Gibran Academy” is essentially a vicious rant against Deborah Almontaser in particular and the “education world sinking into the sea” in general, I am glad it was published.

Baby Einstein not so smart

I read with interest your News Briefs item on the Baby Einstein tapes [Sept. 6 issue] reported from the Denver Post. I, too, objected to a Baby Einstein tape, but for a different reason.

The UFT has taken us a long way

How delightful to belong to an organization that continually looks out for the welfare of its members!

Unexpected victories

I came home feeling like I had just won the lottery.

Sticking points

I saw a bumper sticker today that encouraged me. It said, “Steam Pipe Fitters Union: UNIONS — The folks who brought you the weekend.”

Lower class sizes, better resources should be priorities

Pouring limited resources into merit pay and not into lowering classroom size and providing adequate classroom resources should bring a cry of outrage from every teacher in New York City.

Push for para pension bill

I would like to know if the union spent any time on Bill A 08529, which would allow paraprofessionals and former paraprofessionals to join the tier they would have been entitled to join if they were able to when hired.

When is it OK to touch a student?

This is in reference to the Sept. 6 Speakout column, “Being denied the privilege to teach,” by Leonard Brown.

Schools should be closed on Easter Monday

Upon review of this year’s calendar, it seems that Easter Monday (the day after Easter Sunday) is not recognized as a holiday on the school calendar and spring recess is determined by the date on which Passover falls.

Bush's compassion questioned

George W. Bush has stated that he is a “compassionate conservative.” Some compassion!

Fight for pension increases

We need the help of those working to fight for a pension increase. Remember, one day, all of you will be retired too.

Clarification needed on prior experience

While it is true that the current contract allows for placement on a high step equal to past teaching experience out of the city, that prior experience credit does not apply to longevity steps.

Reading teachers important to middle schools

While a Middle School Task Force has been created, many middle school reading teachers have been excessed in District 21.

Thanks, UFT

We are all so quick to complain that I would like to take this opportunity to express my appreciation to the UFT.

Showing the way

I would like to congratulate UFT President Randi Weingarten on her efforts to bring true professional status to New York City teachers.

Argument against military recruiters inaccurate

I am disappointed that my name was misspelled in the article “Delegates vote to oppose supplying military recruiters with student information," which is symptomatic of the inaccuracies expressed at the [June 13] Delegate Assembly about campus recruiting.

Irrelevant bulletin boards

An administrator told us that our classroom bulletin boards were to have examples of student work prominently displayed. Although there may be value to such displays, I have found them to be somewhat immaterial to teaching and learning.

Don’t turn back the clock

An Arabic cultural school? Why in a public system? As a longtime UFT member and a delegate, I find myself puzzled and rather upset about the policy of the DOE and our union policy.

Achieving students rate recognition, too

A parent is outraged by the absence of teachers from a ceremony to honor high-achieving English students.

More of same is misguided thinking

The narrative over increased standardized testing throughout the school year must move from quantitative to qualitative.

‘T’ an endangered species

As a lover of the English language, and a school retiree, I must apprise you of the “murder” of the English language.

Bring-troops-home vigil in N.J.

I would like to bring to the attention of my fellow New York City public school teachers a large vigil in Teaneck, N.J., that will be held on Wednesday, May 30, during Memorial Week.

Bring in Big Brother

The process for improving and maintaining quality classroom teaching resides in the old process of administrative oversight.

Headline upsets member

I was dismayed and upset at your headline in the April 12 issue: “They tried to kill us, we survived; let’s eat.” This is the punchline of a lame ethnic joke that has no place in our UFT paper.

Sub makes a suggestion

As a substitute teacher, I would like to offer the following suggestions to teachers who currently use SubCentral to obtain their substitute teachers.

Where was principal during fight?

The principal at IS 291 has vowed that the substitute teacher who allegedly did nothing to break up a fight in his classroom will not teach again in another school. Where were the principal, assistant principals and security guards when the fight broke out?

An easy fix for Social Security

Repairing Social Security is very, very simple! Increase the cap from $97,500 to an individual’s total income.

Private school perks for public schools

With all the money being constantly thrown away at failed programs by Mike and Joel, it seems to me that privatizing the public schools is their main goal.

Heartened by DA resolution on military recruiters

I was heartened by the Delegate Assembly resolution toban military recruiters from the schools.

Whistle-blower still paying price

The New York Teacher recently published an in-depth article [“Whistle-blower axed again,” March 15] on the price I paid and am still paying for having been a whistle-blower.

Thanks for article on student

Since I received the April 26 issue of New York Teacher, I have been reading the article “Suzanne Lustig: A living influence” over and over.

Leaving children behind

While there have been reports of improved student achievement in test results, my colleagues and I across the city have come to question the validity of these results.

Empowerment, not dictatorship

We sometimes give glorified names to make things sound as if they are something that in fact they are not. The term “empowerment schools” is just one example.

Test questions that flunk

After reading Sarah Allen’sdescription of the flawed tests we are inflicting on our students, I wrote to The New York Times (unpublished) regarding problems with this year’s 6th-grade ELA:

Principal, AP portrayed unfairly by teacher

As a special education teacher at PS 23, Queens, for the past 19 years, as chapter leader of the school for the past two and as a union member and a person committed to all that education means to a civil and free society, I am appalled by the one-sided attack in the Feb. 15 issue of the New York Teacher.

Sensitivity training needed

It was with deep contempt and sadness that I read about the incident at PS 23, Queens, where a teacher claims to have been harassed due to her orthodox Jewish beliefs.

Staff disappointed by article

We, the staff of PS 23, Queens, at St. Mary’s Hospital for Children under the leadership of Phyllis Weinfeld, wish to respond to the article appearing in the Feb. 15 issue of the New York Teacher.

Hopes there’s no repercussions

Thanks so much for your sensitive article describing the difficult situation Ruth Wenig finds herself in at her assigned school.

Technology without training is wasted

While everything in [the Feb. 15] Speakout [“Technology and teaching should go hand in hand”] is true, too many parts are missing to make technology viable in a New York City classroom.

No loss for material

I retired in 1991, having had my share of experiences with incompetent administrators.

Whistle-blower an ‘amazing teacher’

I am so sorry to read of David Pakter’s ordeal at the HS of Art and Design [“Whistle-blower axed — again,” March 15].

Klein-Bloomberg system a model?

After reading the article “Klein and Bloomberg: Modelers of school governance for a nation,” which was originally printed in the Jan. 16 issue of The Economist — I can only shake and shiver in my boots.

Let military explain opportunities

I was disappointed by the Delegate Assembly voting to ban military recruiters from the schools.

Money must reduce class size

The new money coming from the state to the city of New York with the sole intent of improving the quality of public education should be spent in its entirety on reducing class size.

Parking problems

My co-workers and I have been ticketed for parking next to the school building in which we work for the last two days — this despite the fact that the teachers in this building have been parking here for several years.

Bad scheduling

I don’t understand why Lobby Day was scheduled the same day that the standardized math tests were being administered.

The space squeeze

Teachers need more schools and rooms to serve our kids better.

Lost humanities

Has Brooklyn Tech become a vocational school?

Scrap the scrap paper rule

Would someone explain to me why the Powers That Be would take away something from at-risk children that may help them succeed on a high-stakes exam?

Mr. Klein, are you listening?

It’s been one hot seat after another for Chancellor Klein these past two months, and rightly so.

Mayoral control is a failure

The Alliance of Concerned Teachers, of which I am chairman, is disappointed that class size was not a demand in recent contracts.

Bloomberg plan off-base

Mayor Bloomberg says he would make principals more accountable by giving “public letter-graded reports based largely on their students’ annual standardized test scores.” Doesn’t he know what that does to a curriculum?

Cutting the Daily News down to size

In reading the Jan. 29 Daily News editorial “Cutting Randi down to size,” I couldn’t help wondering about two things.

What about 55-25?

In her Jan. 18 column in the New York Teacher, Randi Weingarten lists several “big issues” going forward. To my great dismay, the 55-25 pension legislation was not among them.

Bus-ted!

This school bus situation is a disgrace for all seasons, let alone winter.

Principal didn’t deserve paper’s

How did one New York Teacher reporter get from a brief telephone conversation on the facts surrounding a grievance to a diatribe on credentials?

Test at students’ instructional levels

State-mandated grade-level exams should not be administered to students with low IQs, or to students reading more than one year below grade level.

Teachers must also determine tenure

It was disturbing that the mayor wants to use retired principals as well as standing principals to get rid of teachers without tenure.

UFT sponsored soccer players

I was happy to read the article about our two high school coaches who took a team of public school soccer players to Ghana for games over the holiday break.

Brooklyn Night also on chopping block

The Department of Education is not closing five high schools, as you report in the Jan. 18 issue. It is closing six!

Longer not necessarily better

This writer was disappointed to hear Gov. Eliot Spitzer's call for longer school days and years and his proposal concerning teacher tenure.

Administrators should teach

This writer suggests that the UFT, in future contract negotiations, ask that all principals and administrative personnel be required teach a class or two.

Teachers must also determine tenure

This writer was disturbed "that the mayor wants to use retired principals as well as standing principals to get rid of teachers without tenure."

Take part in Bell vigil

This writer urges members to join the vigil for Sean Bell, who died in a hail of police bullets on Nov. 26.

Police deserve due process

This writer is "outraged at the UFT for joining a march for justice for Sean Bell, especially when the agenda was ... one of convicting police officers before the evidence was even presented to a grand jury."

To the rescue!

In the middle of a recent reading lesson, elementary school teacher Kristine Ritchie found herself playing a role she never dreamed of — that of a life-saver.

UFT must oppose U.S. policy in Iraq

We have just read the NYSUT resolution on U.S. policy in Iraq. We have been waiting impatiently for three years for the UFT to announce a similar resolution.

Late games present problems

am very concerned about some late starting times for basketball games that have been imposed by the Public Schools Athletic League.

‘Policy, not math, is what has failed’

Regarding the Dec. 7 Speakout column by Roberta Eisenberg [“Math failures — haven’t we heard this before?”], I believe “policy failures” would have been a more appropriate term than “math failures.”

Another hero school

Thomas J. McCann was a former student in our middle school some time ago and he was also a firefighter who was killed on 9/11.

‘Bullying’ beats down teacher

There are a lot a great teachers who will be leaving this system due to the constant bullying by the administration as well as the emotional stress and abuse, sometimes physical, from the students.

New governor off base

One recent night, while I was still working on paperwork for school, I heard the TV in the background and an announcement that our new governor is proposing longer school days and longer school years.

Anti-animal-suffering packets available

For the author who wrote, “I only wish that for each child whose hand held a copy of ... the new publication of the New York Beef Industry Council, that their other hand would grasp a publication on the horrors of suffering that animals endure" — help is on the way!

An F for mayor’s speech

Many people are applauding Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s State of the City address. To me, it was still another attack on the average citizens of this city.

Working conditions need improvement

I teach five classes in a trailer. When I am not using that trailer, another teacher is in it. I usually carry three bags with me, plus an umbrella and a few miscellaneous books in my arms.

Veteran feels betrayed by union

I feel that it was a slap in the face by my union and UFT President Randi Weingarten to go to the Veterans Day Parade and give a speech praising the Veterans.

Class size should have been on table

While the UFT is congratulating itself on the recently negotiated contract because of the economic gains and “no givebacks,” I must question why there were no “takebacks” under discussion?

Toussaint deserved ‘Foolhardy Award’

I am at a loss to understand why the UFT continues to extol the misstep of the TWU in striking in December 2005.

TWU article on target

Thanks for the great article on the TWU. I agree with you l00 percent and try to compliment every transit worker I see on the important job they are doing for the city under the most adverse circumstances.

UFT-TWU connection important

I wish that many more of our colleagues would understand the struggles and battles that were fought in the past.

Principal: Congratulations on contract

A principal writes to UFT President Randi Weingarten to let her know how much she admires her tenacity and dedication on behalf of UFT members.

Do teachers outgrow need for respect?

For too many administrators, good pedagogy seems to stop at the feet of the teacher.

Beef with beef

I only wish that for each child whose hand held a copy of Beef Ag Mag, the new publication from the New York Beef Industry Council, that their other hand would grasp a publication on the horrors of suffering that animals endure.

Says principal not to blame

I am outraged at your [Oct. 19] article which stated that teachers were “united” against the principal at PS 276 in Brooklyn. While I cannot speak for others, I had no indication that the school environment was “toxic.”

Thanks from a retiree

Thanks and kudos to Barbara Shiller and Sasha Green of the Retired Teacher Chapter who advised retirees residing in Northern California about health benefits.

A great column

Kudos and congratulations on your new column in The New York Times, “What Matters Most.” It was well-written and the content was clear, relevant and to the point. Your tone was respectful while being forceful.

Veterans Day outrage

I have been a teacher in the New York public school system for 18 years. This year, however, is the first year I will be expected to teach on Veteran’s Day.

The response was immediate

I am writing because I would like my colleagues and fellow union members to look at both sides of the coin.

This election critical for seniors

Next month’s election will be critical for the future of the big items: Social Security, health-care benefits and pensions.

Appreciates mention of unionist

I was delighted to note that James Connolly, the militant trade unionist, was mentioned in the report on the Labor Parade in the Oct. 5 edition of New York Teacher.

Another school named for hero

You erroneously cite PS 222, the Christopher A. Santora School in Jackson Heights, as the only public school named after a fallen 9/11 hero in your Oct. 5 issue.

Unfair comparison

It’s deceptively simple to randomly compare school districts from around the state.

Veterans Day should be observed

I am appalled that the Department of Education is not closing the schools on Nov. 10 in observance of Veterans Day.

Tech teacher thanks UFT

This letter is a “thank you” note to the officers of the UFT from the chapter leader at Brooklyn Technical HS.

Nike’s terrible message

As a former New York City teacher, I cringed when I watched a new Nike commercial on television a few minutes ago.

The real answer

Common sense by now should tell us that the real answer to good education is for teachers and students to be in smaller classes.

This is a crucial issue

The writer of a letter taking the UFT president to task for not concentrating solely on "bread-and-butter issues" is rebutted.

Article insulted secretaries

It is the school’s payroll secretary who is ultimately responsible for processing emergency checks.

Gay marriage stand divisive

President Weingarten recently said at a gay marriage rally, “All New Yorkers who want to marry should be allowed to do so, period.” I doubt that many members go along with such an absolute statement.

Class size must be reduced

In this, the 21st century, more than at any other time in our lives, it is imperative and crucial that we reduce class size.

Thanks from a former ‘swing’ teacher

When I started, fortunately for me, the school had a program to help new teachers by assigning them to participate in classes run by veteran teachers. We were known as “swing” teachers.

Kids have obligation to behave

After reading the comments of school official Michelle Cahill, you don’t have to wonder why the New York City school system faces the problems that it has.

Who’s hard-working?

A recent New York Times editorial, emphasizing how hard our school system’s principals work, noted the “disturbing” reports that large numbers were retiring.

Irrelevant voices

This is a reply to Carol A. McCarthy and a group of her colleagues at Flushing HS who have written to support and praise a supervisor who is named in the UFT age discrimination charge.

Letter raises questions

I am the teacher from Flushing HS that [staff writer] Jim Callaghan cited in his age discrimination article on Feb. 16. I would like to respond to Carol McCarthy’s letter which appeared in your May 25 edition.

Wipe out

I helped grade the 5th-grade math tests at JHS 167, Manhattan, and one of the rules we were told was to not take the extra toilet paper from the students’ bathrooms. Can you believe this was said?

Age discrimination article disputed

The New York Teacher article “Union hits DOE with age discrimination charge” [Feb. 16] ... impugned the character of Celeste Burton, assistant principal of the English Department at Flushing HS.

Where’s the contract?

It is very difficult for us on the front lines to be sure what is and is not acceptable practice. We have always been able to look up this information in our own copies of the newest contract, which were always mailed to us in a timely fashion.

Against cell phones in schools

Teachers in New York City have to put up with enough disruption in their classes each day. They don’t need the added problem of having to deal with cell phones.

Albany’s charters bill for phantom students

Several Albany charter schools claimed the same students on enrollment lists submitted with their bills to the Albany school district prior to the start of school this year.

A contract ditty

Here’s a poem for your readers: It's called "Read the UFT Contract."

Let teachers teach

While housing incentives are great, there is no adequate substitute for a teacher who loves his or her job and the environment in which he or she works.

Challenging Stossel not worth it

Challenging critics like John Stossel to dabble in teaching can be counterproductive, even under the adverse conditions suggested by one retired teacher.

Payback needed for Medicare Part D

The new Medicare Part D prescription law plan went into effect in January. Those members of Congress who voted for it stabbed Medicare recipients in the back.

‘There he goes again!’

Concerning the [March 16] article by Retired Teachers Chapter Leader Tom Pappas headlined “Nation’s health-care crisis getting worse,” my observation is: “There he goes again!”

Frank’s brother ‘delightful’

Malachy McCourt is also a remarkable and wonderful soul.

Why blame the teacher?

It is exceedingly transparent to me when a UFT chapter leader writes a knee-jerk piece that contradicts the facts of an age discrimination case that the UFT has filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Kudos for special ed whistle-blower

God bless Margo Donovan! I am a parent and just happened to come across the account of her testimony in “Whistle-blowing educators recount chilling stories of retaliation” in the March 16 issue of the New York Teacher, and was relieved in a way.

Unfair U-ratings

The underlying fact of the matter is that many U ratings and verbal abuse/corporal punishment accusations are the result of politics, not performance.

A challenge for Stossel

Let "20/20" co-anchor John Stossel walk in our shoes. I guarantee that after the week, he will change his entire attitude and become an advocate for teachers.

Support for Stossel

I agree with John Stossel’s view about our school system, and my union doesn’t represent my view and I suspect a lot of other teachers’ views.

Proud to be a secretary

I have became increasingly aware that many new staff members have no idea that school secretaries are licensed employees, who take a licensing exam very similar to the exams they take.

Grateful for UFT’s support

The following letter was sent to Roger Roth, staffer at the UFT Queens borough office.

Poor use of scorers’ time

A 2nd-grade teacher in Brooklyn tells of the poor planning she had to deal with when she reported to a school to grade the 3rd-grade state math test.

Test-scoring-day inequities

A teacher assigned to grade the new math exams feels the way training of test scorers has been designed and how it's being implemented is unfair.

‘Appalled’ by easing of tuition penalties

This writer is appalled that professional, educated people living out of the city would falsify their home addresses so their children could attend New York City public schools.

Tax and invest to save program

UFT Treasurer Mel Aaronson takes a publication to task for its support for the Bush campaign to privatize Social Security.

Pleased by Curtis HS coverage

As both an alumnus and a 25-year faculty member, I was pleased that Curtis HS was featured in a recent New York Teacher issue.

‘Astonished’ by Tech changes

I was astonished by recent New York Teacher articles about my old high school, Brooklyn Tech. I attended Tech from 1948 to 1952, and I hardly recognize it as depicted.

Stopping bully principals

Here are some alumni viewpoints about the former principal of Brooklyn Technical HS, Lee McCaskill.

Belief in system should be rewarded

I was recently in New York City visiting my daughter, Asante Denis, who is a 2nd-grade teacher at PS 9 in the Bronx. I retired from the Department of Education in 2004 and have been an active and vocal advocate for public education for more than 25 years. I raised my daughter in the New York City public schools as a vote of confidence for the system.

Yet another challenge

I am writing in response to your “20/20” piece that aired Jan. 13. As a UFT member, a teacher, a parent whose children attend local Bronx public schools and as a citizen, I was outraged at your biased and totally unfounded portrayal of my work, my colleagues’ work and the job that we do to educate the children of the city of New York.

Walk a week in my shoes

I recently viewed your “Stupid in America” segment which presented your opinions as to why American schools are failing. The segment — in my opinion, of course — was one-sided, narrow-minded, misleading and grossly exaggerated. But I’m sure you’ve heard all this before.

Stossel’s bad journalism

This is in reference to the recent article on John Stossel’s unfair “20/20” segment. I am a New York City teacher and a proud member of the UFT. I have been receiving the New York Teacher for many years now. I am glad that you exposed the Stossel segment for what it was: unfair and biased.

600 more reasons to thank the UFT

I just received my $600 [optional rider] reimbursement. Every time we receive a benefit, my husband, who is not a retired teacher, says, “Wow, that is some union that you have.” I wanted to tell you that I agree.

Delayed opening would have helped

We are writing this e-mail [on Feb. 5] from the borough of Queens and have just been notified that all New York City public schools will be open after the largest snowstorm in New York City history.

What teachers make

Teachers make a difference, as the following letter illustrates.

Weighing in on benefits costs

As reported on the front page of the [Feb. 2] issue of New York Teacher, it is no secret that the city intends to attack our health benefits in the next round of bargaining — that is, if it ever gets around to serious bargaining.

Union plan would have saved $$

The UFT's proposals for the use of the extended time in the new contract were far more sensible from an economic, educational and logistical point of view than those pushed by the city.

Hit ‘20/20’ sponsors

In addition to the uft picketing the ABC offices, uft members as well as other unions in New York City and our supporters, should boycott the products of sponsors of “20/20.”

Stossel’s one-hour-per-week job

Someone should ask John Stossel how many people he knows who uniformly work one hour per week.

Day lasts long after final bell

John Stossel should spend a week in a teacher’s shoes before he claims that the work week is a “uniform week of 6 hours and 40 minutes.”

Principal ‘collegial, supportive’

I am writing on behalf of my chapter, about the [Feb. 16] article in the New York Teacher headlined “Union hits DOE with age discrimination charge.”

Support for principal

In my 25-odd years as chapter leader of Boys and Girls HS, I must say that Frank Mickens was the least objectionable of all the myriad principals that I dealt with.

Right move, wrong reason

I’m trying to comprehend the steps that led to Lee McCaskill’s ouster as principal at Brooklyn Tech.

Restoring Tech’s legacy

I can just hear the Brooklyn Tech students who were called “dumb asses” by their disgraced former principal, Lee McCaskill, saying to themselves, Who’s the dumb ass now?

Tutoring plan lacks needed standards

Working in a system driven by standards, I find it sad but not surprising that there is none for mandating students’ participation in the extra 371/2-minute “tutoring” sessions.

Gibbs prof remains hopeful

Thank you for your recent article in the New York Teacher concerning the plight of the instructors at the Katharine Gibbs School [“Gibbs profs’ contract talks ‘stalled,” Feb. 2].

Column was right on

Tom Pappas’ [Feb. 15] article “No one is safe” was a good reminder to retirees and others who think that because they don’t work or haven’t worked for employers the likes of Wal-Mart that they don’t have to worry about being without adequate health benefits or a pension.

Kudos for column

Jim Callaghan’s Labor Spotlight column [“Teachers the real heroes at Brooklyn Tech,” March 2] was one of the best columns ever to be printed in the New York Teacher.

Slap at principal unfair

As an alumnus of Brooklyn Tech and as a retired 26-year faculty member of Boys and Girls HS, I feel I am in a unique position to comment on your fine articles outlining the retirement of Principal Lee McCaskill.

Why did it take so long?

When the news finally broke that the hard reign of Lee McCaskill, principal of Brooklyn Tech, had at last ended, two truisms came to mind.

Thanks union for help

I would like to commend Randi Weingarten, (special representative) Laura Tamburo and the UFT for helping me with an issue a few weeks ago.

Librarians grateful for articles

Thank you so much for writing the wonderful article featuring librarians in New York City schools [“Not just a ‘book-checker-outer,’” Feb. 2].

Victory not without struggle

I would like to express my appreciation to Jim Callaghan and the rest of UFT for publishing the excellent article outlining my struggles with the Department of Education [“Harassed teacher wins lawsuit with back pay,” Feb. 2].

Extended time comes at a cost

A teacher and therapist wonders if there will be a deleterious effect on the lives of children who have to stay late for the new after-school tutoring.

Tech woes anger alum

A Brooklyn Tech HS alumnus whose father taught at the school is dismayed about what he's been reading lately about his alma mater.

Katrina victim thanks UFT

A retiree who relocated to New Orleans and had to relocate again after Hurricane Katrina is glad her old union is still there for her.

Excessed does not mean incompetent

The Department of Education and the media are making it appear that the 1,000 teachers who were demoted to substitute status are unsatisfactory. This is not the truth.

Special ed changes not succeeding

A school social worker says changes to special education have produced terrible consequences.

New drug plan misses mark

A member is pleased that retired UFT members' prescription drug plan will be better than the typical Medicare plan, but wishes she still had the old plan.

Medicare drug program a loser

A member expresses her nger about the new Medicare prescription drug program.

The right Rx

An RTC member congratulates the UFT Welfare Fund executive director for the comprehensive way he explained the Medicare Part D changes at a recent meeting.

A proud, traditional teacher

A retiree submits that there was nothing wrong with the way she used to teach: with students sitting in rows and teaching with only a piece of chalk.

What days teachers want off

A teacher suggests eliminating the February break in exchange for the two days before Labor Day members now must work.

Extended time is poorly planned

A member speaks out on the extended-time section of the new contract.

Thankful for a new piano

An elementary school teacher thanks individuals who helped her school replace its broken-down piano.

Brooklyn Tech teachers sound off

A veteran teacher at Brooklyn Technical HS responds after a local newspaper columnist accused UFT members of using racial code words that "trigger thoughts of racism and tend to polarize people" in their efforts to shed light on failings of their principal.

Cronyism wins out

A teacher from Brooklyn Technical HS responds to articles about his school that have appeared recently in the New York Teacher.

Login



NEWS AND ISSUES
MEMBER SERVICES
MY CHAPTER
NEW TEACHERS
ABOUT US
UFT CALENDAR
WELFARE FUND
HOTLINE
Election 08 The New York Teacher Edwize - UFT Blog UFT Providers parent conference - UFT Blog Political Action UFT Course Catalog Randi's School Visits Randi's NY Times columns
Copyright © 2008 United Federation of Teachers
Home
Login
Register
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Search