Skip to main content
Full Menu Close Menu

What to do if your LODI is medically denied

If your LODI request for 20 or more consecutive school days was denied medically (as opposed to administratively) by the doctors at the DOE, you have the option to apply for medical arbitration. You should probably apply for medical arbitration even if you later choose not to pursue it. Members who have a pending medical arbitration request will automatically be granted a leave of absence for the denied period which will provide them with medical benefits and the ability to apply to the UFT Welfare Fund for disability payments.

  1. Members are only eligible for medical arbitration if their cases are medically denied for at least 20 consecutive days. You have ten business days from the date you were informed of the LODI denial in order to file for arbitration.
  2. Fill out the medical arbitration form that you got from Tom Bennett or your local UFT rep. Choose the type of doctor you would like to act as your arbitrator (usually orthopedist or neurologist), choose the doctor you would like the arbitrator to talk to (i.e. your doctor), and choose the type of arbitration it is (LODI). Then fill in the dates of denied LODI. If the injury is ongoing and you have not returned to work, put “to present” as the end date.
  3. Scan the arbitration application and email it to, with a copy to Tom Bennett at and/or your local UFT rep.
  4. A day or so after filing for medical arbitration, you should receive an "eligibility letter” from the DOE. This letter says you are qualified for arbitration and have been placed on the list.
  5. At this point, you have a gap in your service history that needs to be filled. You will have to go onto SOLAS and ask for a special arbitration leave. It is called a “restoration of health pending medical arbitration.” Select the dates starting with the first date of your LODI denial up to the day before you went back to work. If you don’t know when you’re going back to work discuss the best date with Tom Bennett and/or your local rep. You can elect to borrow 20 CAR days but you can’t get a grace period.
  6. Remember, you only upload the eligibility letter as documentation for the arbitration leave. No medical documentation is required.
  7. An arbitration leave is a leave without pay but you can use CAR days. Once you run out of CAR days, you can apply to the UFT Welfare Fund for disability payments of $475/week and you are kept on medical benefits for one year after the date you come off payroll provided you have an approved leave in SOLAS. 
  8. The DOE reviews all arbitrated LODIs to see if they were handled correctly. This process is known as "stipulation review." So, you may hear from the DOE in a month or so with an offer to accept more LODI in exchange for dropping the arbitration case. Sometimes the offer is very generous, up to the entire LODI. You should reach out to Tom Bennett if you get an offer so we can discuss the merits of the case.
  9. The wait for the actual arbitration is at least three years and the member must pay $800. The DOE also pays $800.

Potential issues:

  1. Sometimes members have been kept on payroll during a long wait to get their LODI's approved. They may not have had the sick days to cover that. Hence, the DOE is going to take that money back as soon as you start working again at the rate of 25% of each paycheck. The DOE doesn't wait for the arbitration case to occur. They take the money back now.
  2. Sometimes the denied LODI period doesn't represent all the LODI that the member wanted. For example, they were denied from 1/1/22 to 2/1/22, but are still out after that. They should put the word "to present" on their arbitration form rather than a particular end date. That signals to the DOE that the LODI is actually longer than what they see in SOLAS.


  1. Medically denied LODI of 20 or more days.
  2. File for medical arbitration. Perhaps put "to present" on end date of LODI.
  3. Await eligibility letter (usually comes in a day or two).
  4. Apply for restoration of health pending medical arbitration, from first denied LODI date to whenever member returns to work.
  5. Upload only the eligibility letter into SOLAS to support the arbitration leave.
  6. Look for possible stipulation offer to resolve the LODI/arbitration entirely. This usually takes a month or so.
  7. If off payroll, apply to the UFT Welfare Fund for disability payments of $475/week. Call the Welfare Fund at (212) 539- 0500.
  8. Await arbitration which could take 3 years.

Download a summary of the medical arbitration process »

If you have further questions or concerns, please call UFT Medical Representative Thomas Bennett at (212) 598-7711 or email him at